• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

The Conner Law Firm, LLC HomepageThe Conner Law Firm, LLC

Call Us Now!

(618) 277-2421
Schedule A Consultation
  • Home
  • Erin K. Conner
  • Practice Areas
    • DUI
      • Aggravated DUI
      • First Offense DUI
      • Felony DUI
      • Commercial Driver DUI
      • Underage DUI
    • Violent Crimes
      • Murder Defense
      • Armed Robbery
      • Aggravated Battery
      • Home Invasion Defense
    • Domestic Violence
    • Sex Crimes
    • Weapons Charges
    • Drug Crimes
    • Theft & Burglary
    • Misdemeanors
    • Traffic Violations
    • Juvenile Defense
    • Orders of Protection
    • Expungement
    • Criminal Appeals
    • Probation Violation
    • Driver’s License Reinstatement
  • Resource
    • Areas Served
    • Case Results
    • Reviews
    • Latest News
    • FAQ
  • Contact Us
CALL US NOW
EMAIL US NOW
A defense attorney working at a laptop with a gavel on the desk

Why Hire a Former Prosecutor for DUI Defense?

Oct 26, 2026 by The Conner Law Firm

A former prosecutor has already sat on the other side of the table in DUI cases. They know how the State evaluates evidence, where DUI cases tend to be weak, and how far the State will typically move in negotiation. That experience can give your defense real leverage when your license, your record, and your freedom are on the line. At The Conner Law Firm, Attorney Erin K. Conner brings eight years of experience at the St. Clair County State’s Attorney’s Office to DUI cases in Belleville and throughout St. Clair, Madison, and Monroe Counties and southern Illinois.

Knowing How the Case Was Built

Prosecutors make charging decisions, set plea offers, and decide what to pursue in an Illinois DUI case. Whether it’s your first DUI or you’ve been down this road before, an attorney who used to work for the prosecution reads a police report the way the State does, because they have made charging decisions based on reports just like yours.

They compare the written police report frame by frame against the bodycam and dashcam video, looking for contradictions. They question whether the officer had a lawful reason to make the traffic stop in the first place and probable cause to make the arrest. They also scrutinize field sobriety tests and chemical test results. The State looks for video of a defendant slurring their speech or admitting to drinking, but a former prosecutor who now defends DUI cases knows how to identify the inconsistencies that undermine that evidence. When the evidence is weakened, the State may be more willing to reduce the charge or dismiss the case.

Seeing the Weaknesses the State Hopes You Miss

One of the questions to ask before hiring a DUI defense attorney is what strategy they plan to use to fight your charges. A former prosecutor has stood in the State’s shoes, so they can spot gaps in what the State must prove to convict you, such as whether you were actually impaired or whether you were driving or in actual physical control of the vehicle.

In Belleville DUI cases, problems often arise in how roadside tests and chemical tests are administered. Field sobriety tests are scored by the officer and are widely criticized as subjective, and breath testing requires a properly trained operator, a required observation period, and a properly certified and calibrated instrument. When the police report doesn’t match what the video shows, that can give us a strong foothold in fighting the charges you’re facing.

Knowing the Real Negotiation Ceiling

Another advantage of hiring a former prosecutor involves the standing offer, which is the plea deal the State puts on the table early in your case. That first offer is often not the State’s actual limit, and knowing where the limit really is can change whether you should accept a plea or keep fighting. That judgment is not guesswork. It comes from years of setting those offers from the other side of the table, and it directly shapes how a former prosecutor defends clients facing DUI charges.

You can read our complete guide to hiring a DUI lawyer in Belleville, where you’ll learn more about how much a DUI lawyer costs in Illinois and what to expect from the process.

Attorney Insight

“I spent eight years deciding which DUI cases to charge and what to offer. I know where the State’s case is weakest, and I know when an offer isn’t really the State’s final word.” — Erin K. Conner, former Chief of the Criminal Bureau, St. Clair County State’s Attorney’s Office

Erin K. Conner’s Background

The Conner Law Firm is led by Erin K. Conner, former Chief of the Criminal Bureau at the St. Clair County State’s Attorney’s Office, who now defends DUI cases in Belleville, Illinois. Attorney Erin K. Conner’s background includes eight years at the St. Clair County State’s Attorney’s Office, where she rose from line Assistant State’s Attorney to Supervisor of the Violent Crimes Unit and then Chief of the Criminal Bureau. She also served as an instructor with the Southern Illinois Law Enforcement Commission, training law enforcement officers like the ones whose DUI reports and procedures she now scrutinizes on behalf of clients.

During her time serving the State, she prosecuted aggravated DUI cases, including cases involving death and permanent disfigurement. Now Attorney Conner defends clients facing DUI charges in the same courthouse. Illinois treats DUI charges seriously, and the details that decide these cases are easy to miss. Our Belleville DUI defense lawyer knows where to look for them.

Talk to a Former Prosecutor About Your DUI Case

If you were arrested for DUI in Belleville or anywhere in St. Clair, Madison, or Monroe Counties or southern Illinois, the sooner an experienced attorney is reviewing your case, the more options you may have. Your license is on a clock, too, because Illinois gives you only a limited window to challenge a statutory summary suspension. Call (618) 277-2421 or text (314) 944-5553 to schedule your consultation and see why hiring a former prosecutor can make a difference in your defense.

Filed Under: DUI Defense, Hiring a DUI Lawyer

    Contact a Criminal Defense Attorney in Belleville, IL Today

    Disclaimer | Privacy Policy

    Practice Areas

    • Criminal Appeals
    • Domestic Violence
    • Driver’s License Reinstatement
    • Drug Crimes
    • DUI
      • Aggravated DUI
      • First Offense DUI
      • Felony DUI
    • Expungement
    • Juvenile Defense
    • Misdemeanor Defense
    • Order of Protection
    • Probation Violation
    • Sex Crimes
    • Theft & Burglary
    • Traffic Violations
    • Violent Crimes
      • Murder Defense
    • Weapons Charges

    Trial Experience

    50+ Trials
    Criminal Cases Tried to Verdict

    Erin K. Conner has handled serious criminal matters from both the prosecution and defense side.

    Learn More

    Reviews

    Client Reviews

    Read client feedback and learn more about The Conner Law Firm’s approach to criminal defense representation.

    View Reviews
    • Homepage
    • Erin K. Conner
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Latest News
    • Reviews
    • 5111 West Main Street,
      Belleville, IL 62226
    • Phone:
      (618) 277-2421
    • Text:
      (314) 944-5553
    • Email:
      erin@theconnerlawfirm.com
    • Mon–Fri : 9am–5pm,
      After Hours : By Appointment
    Get Direction
    LinkedIn Instagram
    Click to activate map

    © 2026 The Conner Law Firm LLC. All Rights Reserved. | Terms of Service | Sitemap | Privacy Policy